亜田夢, kiokuchan, rasune7, and 9 others are discussing. Toggle Comments
definitely a fan!
I’m a fan of her, not so much a fan of her music ^^”
i like her but they should really market her like how they did with ayaya. she may not have the voice, but since she’s tech the only soloist with so-so sales, they need to think of something else fast… H!P is losing my interest music wise (go akb48!) but i’m still interested with their projects of course.
I couldn’t chose- I both think she’s a talentless bore, and I’d prefer a different soloist!
I’m a fan of her and her Music, but it’d be nice to hear her with a different style; hopefully, a Album would appease that.
But she really needs a variation in her Music, since her vocals are starting to remain the same skill. She’s improving, yes, but not as quick as she should be–not as a Soloist. But she does have a unique voice, so I’m starting to doubt the type of skill she can make out of it… >,>
And I’d also like H!P to have another [few] EGGS become Soloist (this is preferred, over current members such as Airi, etc.!). Lots of them have stronger vocals than ManoEri, but I’m guessing nowhere near as many fans (even a fraction of her’s might be twice as much? XD). Plus, it’d be nice to have at least a couple more Soloists, compared to one [that gets original music]. =3
And, as I’ve said before, her lack of variation in Music is halting her vocal progress. I, personally, think she’s quite talented. However, that doesn’t mean she hasn’t reached the best of her abilities, or even half-way. (I can’t really be sure, because of her unique voice, though… I’m used to voices that are more common. XD)
Basically, to put it simple: If her Music is given more Variation, I think it will both improve her vocals, as well as get more Fans (or just people less “aggressive” towards her).
If she were a “talentless bore”, I wonder how she could’ve gotten chosen as an EGG [amd then debut as a Soloist]~ XD
She ain’t a “Shining Star”, or whatever you’d call them, but she certainly is an entertainer (Idol; Singer, Actress, and Radio Host).
Though, I guess most people don’t like a different style of voice (since her’s is a unique-one), than the average-ones, or it’s her Style [of Music]. >,>
*adds comment after 2 days-whatever*
Tsunku never makes the best decision, now does he? Koharu Kusumi over Suma Ai?? “Talentless bore” is definitely the best decription of her I’ve heard yet XD
Personally, I always wanted Noto Arisa to debut solo~
I love Manoeri, she is very charismatic, funny and tries hard. Although her voice is not the best, I like acting, is always enjoyed and sincere, respectful, courageous and many other things that are missing though other soloists who have a vow Wow if you have no heart to the fans, and other non wotas are nothing.
Sopport Mano Erina.
3rd option all the way.
TRUE DAT!! xDDDD
Lol she’s so bad and boring.
But I think she’s a wota’s dream girl. A legal girl who looks 10 years old.
whatever, you guys are just being haters. thats right i used the word “haters”. She pretty much has the same amount of talent as any other girl in H!P. and since when has it been a bad or new thing for H!P to employ a pretty girl who can’t sing (they’ve been doing it for years now) just because she is a soloist now doesn’t mean you should start pointing out how talentless she is. how about why does risako get so many solo lines in Berryz? because she just does, thats whats been decided. why is mano erina a soloist? because she just is, they are trying to do something new with her. and frankly i don’t think her voice sounds bad.
So its okay for her to be bad at singing since someone else is ?
Also when you become an entertainer you open yourself to criticism.
yeah in H!P standards i guess so. and obviously if someone is criticizing soneone i like i would voice my opinion on the matter. it’s my opinion, just like how it was in my opinion that Kanna wasn’t as great so i don’t miss her at all.
Talentless bore, definitely. I honestly don’t see her appeal personality or looks-wise, and she’s definitely among the least-talented members in H!P, and she doesn’t seem to be improving at all. She’s actually replaced Koharu as my least favorite H!P member. And for me, that’s really saying something. XD
As for being a “hater,” if, in my personal opinion, Mano’s a below-average singer, a just-barely-average dancer, has a personality that doesn’t appeal to me even a little, releases music that puts me to sleep (and I’m female so I couldn’t care less about her looks), what do I have to like about her? Nothing. Yes, there are plenty of members who can’t sing well, or dance well, or who are boring or even a bit irritating to me, but they make up for their shortcomings in other ways, so I don’t dislike them (maybe they can’t sing but have an interesting/funny/likable personality, for example, or their personality is boring or unappealing but they have a great voice, etc…). Mano *doesn’t* make up for her shortcomings, so she remains generally unlikable to me. I have legitimate reasons for not liking her (which are my personal opinions and views that I don’t expect everyone to share). I don’t think that makes me a hater.
I think the term “hater” is stupid and for someone to genuinely hate an idol they need to have some serious free time.
As some long-time readers may or may not know I’ve always had an issue with Kusumi Koharu, namely her role as a key member of Momusu, but I think you need to give an idol her dues when she does well (Kusumi = Balalaika).
Mano’s 4th single is actually pretty cute and her voice sounds more gentle, less yelpy.
lol i had no idea which other word to use, thats why i put it in quotes. anyways i agree and i think idols should be givin a chance, they eventually do something good anyways. besieds overly critical ppl are annoying. tho i don’t think there would be much dues to pay to kanna so i still won’t miss her, mainly because she didn’t do anything.
^ Same, Kanna did nothing for me because she was given nothing to do :P
Required fields are marked *
Notify me of new comments via email.
← Morning Musume C/W Collection (2009-10-07)
Mano Erina 4th Single – “Kono Mune no Tokimeko wo” Radio Preview →
Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.